On this page
On this page
8 min read
You pay the premium every year. You probably have not read the policy past the first few pages. Most owners find out what their policy says on the day they file a claim.
This guide covers the policies a flight school carries, what sets the price, and where the gaps tend to hide. It draws on our podcast interview with Beth Clark, an aviation insurance specialist at Marsh McLennan Agency. Quotes come from the episode recording, with a link to the moment she said each one.
This is general information, not advice for your policy. Your policy wording and your broker decide what you are covered for.
The policies a flight school carries
Flight school insurance is not one policy. Beth listed the pieces most schools start with (6:28):
- A fleet policy. This covers your aircraft. Hull coverage pays for damage to the airplane, and liability pays for damage the airplane does to others. The carrier first asks what you fly and what you teach: piston, multi-engine, turbine, or jet.
- General liability. Students and visitors walk your ramp and your office. General liability covers your premises.
- Coverage for your CFIs. This protects the school when a student claims the instruction was negligent. Some carriers put it on the fleet policy, and some put it on general liability. Beth said neither place is better (8:38). What matters is that the wording covers how your school works.
- Workers’ compensation. Whether you need it depends on how you hire. Instructors on W-2 and instructors on 1099 are treated differently.
What sets your price
An underwriter prices your school on a short list of things (9:42):
- Part 141 or Part 61. A Part 141 school runs under more FAA structure. Beth said underwriters can find that more attractive, and may offer a Part 141 school higher liability limits than a Part 61 school.
- Your loss history. Fewer claims, better terms.
- Your aircraft types. Some carriers will not write certain aircraft in a flight school because of past losses.
- Your aircraft age. This one surprises owners.
The older airplane is not always cheaper
Owners often buy an older airplane to save on insurance. The hull value is lower, so the premium looks lower. But Beth said the rate on an older airplane is often higher, because parts are harder to find (11:43).
That shows up in a claim. If an airplane sits for six months waiting on a part, it is not flying lessons. Loss of use coverage would pay for that time, but Beth said it is not common on school rental policies (14:38). If you need it, ask for it by name.
Call your broker before you change the fleet
Adding a helicopter, a new type of airplane, or a location in another state can change your policy in the middle of the term. Beth said many carriers do not want rotor wing in a flight school at all, so a new helicopter can mean a new carrier (23:22). Ask before you buy, and ask whether your current CFIs will need more training to fly it.
The same goes for an airplane you add through an aircraft leaseback. Settle whose policy covers it before it flies its first lesson.
Who pays when a student damages an airplane
This is where most schools get caught. Many students carry a non-owned renter policy, and owners assume that policy pays when the student causes damage. Sometimes it does.
If a student flying solo damages the airplane, the student’s non-owned policy is likely to pay. But put a CFI in the right seat and the answer can change. Beth explained what the student’s carrier may say (17:01):
“That non-owned insurance carrier could point the finger at the school and say, ‘No, your CFI was in the plane. He’s responsible for any damages.’”
Then the claim lands on your policy. She added that this can happen even when the student would not let go of the yoke (18:04).
Should you require students to carry a policy?
That is your business decision, and schools go both ways (19:34). Two things to know:
- Liability-only schools. Some schools carry no hull coverage at all. They require students to carry enough physical damage coverage to pay for the airplane.
- Your students can get turned down. Beth said an underwriter can flag a school that carries no hull coverage. Students at that school may not be able to buy a non-owned policy (20:53).
Non-owned policies are fairly inexpensive, and a student can buy one for as short as 30 days to finish a rating. Some carriers give schools a link students can use to buy a policy directly (50:44).
When your policy covers your CFIs
A CFI teaching in your airplanes, under your rules and your handbook, is generally covered by the school’s policy. Beth said that holds whether the CFI is on W-2 or 1099 (27:34).
It changes when a CFI teaches on their own. If your CFI picks up a student who owns an airplane and charges that student directly, the school’s policy no longer covers that work. That CFI needs a non-owned CFI policy of their own (28:27).
Renting to pilots who are not your students
Some schools rent airplanes to licensed pilots on the weekends to keep them busy. Underwriters price that higher, because the school has less control. Beth said that is where many flight school claims come from (36:03):
“That’s where we see a lot of flight schools have a lot of claims.”
You have two options. Ask your broker what dropping third-party rental would save. Or keep it, and write checkout rules your underwriter can rely on, such as a set number of flights with a CFI and a checkride before any renter takes the airplane out alone (39:52). A broker can bring those rules to the underwriter when you negotiate the rate.
How to lower the premium without losing coverage
The simplest lever is the deductible. Beth said a higher deductible lowers the premium, but you take on more of the risk (35:00). It makes the most sense for a school with a clean record and CFIs you trust.
The next lever is your broker. A local agent is not bad, Beth said, but many are generalists:
“It just means that they’re generalist and they don’t have all the access to all the aviation markets out there.” (24:47)
At the time of the interview, she could reach 14 carriers that would quote a flight school. A helicopter school has far fewer options.
Here is the honest part. The cheapest policy can cost you the most. Beth put it plainly (12:45):
“You get what you pay for. I hate to use that term, but it’s so true.”
Insure your airplanes at what they are worth today
Airplane values have climbed. Beth said a 172 that was valued at $25,000 to $50,000 five years ago is worth a couple hundred thousand dollars now (53:15). If your hull value is still set at the old number and you lose the airplane, the carrier pays the insured value. You cover the rest.
Check every hull value on your fleet policy against what each airplane would cost to replace today.
Questions to ask your broker this year
Each question comes from a point in the interview. Beth suggested the first two before you decide whether to switch brokers (33:56).
- How many aviation carriers can you quote my school with?
- What coverage do I have today, and what am I missing?
- Is my CFI coverage on the fleet policy or general liability, and does the wording fit how my school runs?
- Do I have loss of use coverage?
- Are my hull values set at today’s prices?
- What would a higher deductible save?
- What would dropping third-party rental save, or what checkout rules would lower the rate?
- What changes if I add an aircraft type, a helicopter, or a location in another state?
Do one thing this week: read your policy
When we asked Beth for the one thing every owner should do, she said read the policy, all of it (52:09):
“Insurance policies are, we give you everything up front and then the second couple pages we take it all away.”
The coverage that comes back sits at the end, in the sub-limits and endorsements. If something does not make sense, call your broker before you need it.
Her advice for avoiding surprises was just as short (53:15):
“Just don’t look at the premium solely. Look at the policy limits. Understand the limits. Understand your coverages so you’re not caught off guard.”
The other half: keeping those airplanes busy
A good policy protects the airplanes you have. It does not fill their schedule. If you are paying to insure a fleet, check that your marketing brings in enough students to fly it: how many inquiries you get each month, how many book a discovery flight, and how many of those enroll.
Not sure where those numbers stand? Send your website address and you get a written audit by email, ranked worst to best, at no cost.
More Articles in This Series
This is part 4 of the The Flight School Money Guide series, written to be read in order.
- Cost to Start a Flight School: A Line-by-Line Breakdown. Every startup line item from aircraft to insurance to certification, and where most new owners underestimate.
- Leasing vs. Buying Training Aircraft: The Real Math. Lease, buy, or leaseback: the cash flow, tax, and utilization math behind your training fleet.
- Aircraft Leaseback for Flight Schools: How It Works. Owner leasebacks and sale-leasebacks: how each one adds aircraft, and what each one costs you.
- Flight School Insurance: Coverage, Cost, and Common Gaps. You are here.